Table of Contents
The Cookout Peach milkshake is the second-lightest shake at Cook Out. At 547 calories in a 32.7 oz cup it trails only Fresh Banana, and it typically costs $3.99. It is also the lowest-scored shake on the fan site, tied with Hi-C Punch at 5 of 17, and a 2013 Tripadvisor review said it tasted like hand-churned ice cream.
Why do reviewers disagree about the Peach shake?
The fan scorer found it completely devoid of flavor, though with a great personality. The Daily Meal ranked it 35th of 41 and described peach chunks in vanilla soft serve with no Nilla wafers, leaving the texture uneven and squishy and the peach flavor underwhelming. Mashed was kinder, ranking it 23rd and saying it does a pretty decent job though peach lovers may want a harder punch of fruit.
| Source | Verdict |
|---|---|
| Tripadvisor reviewer, Charlotte, NC | Titled the review "Peach Milkshake Taste Great!" and compared it to hand-churned ice cream |
| The Talon (2018) | 23rd of 43 |
| Mashed | 23rd; decent, but peach lovers may want more fruit |
| The Daily Meal | 35th of 41; uneven squishy chunks, no wafers, underwhelming |
| cookoutmilkshakereviews.com | 5 of 17, tied for last; devoid of flavor with a great personality |
The reviewers agree on the texture and split on whether that matters. A Tripadvisor diner enjoyed the simple peach taste. The critics wanted the structure that wafers give the cobbler version.
How much lighter is Peach than Peach Cobbler?
243 calories lighter. The lightness is the Peach shake's best argument.
| Measure | Peach | Peach Cobbler |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 547 | 790 |
| Size | 32.7 oz | 34.5 oz |
| Cholesterol | 55 mg | 145 mg |
| Sugar | 86 g | 105 g |
Only Fresh Banana, at 538, comes in under it for calories, and Fresh Banana, Banana Pineapple and Vanilla are the other shakes near it.
Is the Cookout Peach milkshake worth choosing over the cobbler?
Order it when you want a peach flavor at 547 calories and can accept a looser texture. Choose Peach Cobbler if texture and flavor matter more than weight.