Table of Contents
The Carrollton Cook Out has the lowest Yelp score of the stores in our location guides and the highest Restaurantji food score we have recorded. Yelp averages 2.6 stars from 48 reviews for the restaurant at 904 S. Park Street, while Restaurantji rates its food 3.9 of 5. The gap tells you what reviewers are rating: the food and shakes earn praise, and the service and order accuracy take the blame.
- 2.6
- Yelp rating
- 3.9
- Food score on Restaurantji
- 93 to 90
- Health inspection scores
- $7.91
- Regular Tray with tax
48 reviews, the lowest in our guides
Service 3.4, atmosphere 3.5
April 2024, then June 2025
Georgia 4% plus Carroll County 3%
Cook Out Carrollton
Open- Address
- 904 S. Park St., Carrollton, GA 30117
- Hours
- 10:30 AM to 3 AM Sunday to Thursday; 10:30 AM to 4 AM Friday and Saturday (Yelp, Restaurantji)
- Drive-thru
- Yes
Why do the Carrollton ratings split so widely?
Because the sites weigh different things. Restaurantji, which scores food, atmosphere and service separately, gives 3.9 for food, 3.5 for atmosphere and 3.4 for service from 311 ratings, a 3.3 overall. Yelp sits at 2.6 from 48 reviews and Tripadvisor at 3.0 from 19. The complaints in review text are consistent: wrong orders, long waits and, in one Tripadvisor review, chicken tenders substituted for filets. Praise goes to the milkshakes and to the store as a late-night stop, and a Yelp reviewer called the food pretty good for late-night college runs.
| Site | Rating | Reviews | What stands out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurantji | 3.3 | 311 | Food 3.9, atmosphere 3.5, service 3.4 |
| Tripadvisor | 3.0 | 19 | Wrong order and a long wait in one review |
| Yelp | 2.6 | 48 | Lowest rating in our location guides |
What do the health inspection scores show?
A passing store whose score slipped. The Times-Georgian's restaurant inspection listings show Cook Out at 904 South Park St. scoring 93 on an April 29, 2024 inspection and 90 on June 12, 2025. Georgia's scale treats 90 to 100 as an A, so the latest listing we found sits at the bottom of that range. The listings are newspaper roundups and may not be complete, and we found no 2026 inspection. The Georgia Department of Public Health's database has the full reports.
April 29, 2024
Inspection score of 93
Listed by the Times-Georgian.
June 12, 2025
Inspection score of 90
The most recent listing we found.
September 2026
Yelp shows 48 reviews
Average 2.6 stars.
What does a tray cost in Carroll County?
Georgia charges 4% and Carroll County adds 3%, for 7% with no city rate, according to Avalara. That matches Oakwood in Hall County. The dollar totals assume the chain's typical menu prices, which Park Street may post differently.
| Order | Menu price | With 7% tax |
|---|---|---|
| Regular Tray | $7.39 | $7.91 |
| Jr. Tray | $6.39 | $6.84 |
| Milkshake | $3.99 | $4.27 |
| Four Regular Trays | $29.56 | $31.63 |
The Oakwood and Atlanta guides cover Georgia's other stores, and the price guide lists the full board.
Is the Carrollton Cook Out worth ordering from?
For the food, yes, and with a check of the bag at the window. Late-night hours run to 3 AM and 4 AM on weekends, and the milkshakes draw the most consistent praise.